Personal Loan vs. Home Equity Loan: 8 Surprising Facts That Will Change How You Borrow
When a significant financial need arises; whether it’s a long-overdue home renovation, a medical emergency, or the desire to consolidate overwhelming debt; two powerful borrowing tools often come to mind: a personal loan and a home equity loan. On the surface, they may seem interchangeable, both offering a lump sum of cash to be repaid over time. However, beneath the surface, they operate on fundamentally different principles.
Choosing the wrong one could cost you thousands of dollars, add unnecessary risk, or delay your project for weeks. To help you make the smartest financial decision for your unique situation, we've compiled 8 surprising facts about personal loans and home equity loans that you probably didn't know. By the end of this article, you will be equipped with the knowledge to select the perfect borrowing option with confidence.
Fact #1: One Puts Your Home at Risk, The Other Doesn't
This is the single most important and foundational difference between these two loan types. A home equity loan is a secured loan, using your home as collateral. The lender places a lien on your property, and if you fail to make payments, they have the legal right to foreclose on your home to recoup their losses. It is essentially a second mortgage.
A personal loan, on the other hand, is typically an unsecured loan. Your home, car, or any other asset is not used as collateral. If you default on the loan, the lender cannot take your home. While defaulting will severely damage your credit score and could lead to collection efforts, the risk of losing your primary residence is eliminated.
The Bottom Line: If the thought of putting your home on the line keeps you up at night, a personal loan offers a much safer, albeit potentially more expensive, alternative.
Fact #2: Their Interest Rates Are Different For a Very Specific Reason
Many people are aware that home equity loans generally offer lower interest rates than personal loans, but few understand the "why." The reason is directly tied to Fact #1: risk.
Because a home equity loan is secured by your home, the risk to the lender is significantly lower. In the event of a default, they can sell your property to recover their money. This reduced risk allows them to offer more competitive, lower interest rates.
Personal loans, being unsecured, carry a higher risk for the lender. If a borrower defaults, the lender has no asset to seize. As a result, they charge a higher interest rate to compensate for this increased risk.
The Bottom Line: Home equity loan interest rates are almost always lower than personal loan rates for the same borrower. If your primary goal is to get the lowest possible interest rate and you're comfortable with the risk, a home equity loan will likely be the better option.
Fact #3: One Has a Faster Funding Time Than the Other, By a Long Shot
Need cash in a hurry for an emergency car repair or a last-minute dental procedure? The speed of funding is a critical factor, and this is where personal loans have a significant edge.
Personal Loans: The application process is typically streamlined and can be completed entirely online in minutes. Since there is no home appraisal or title search required, some online lenders can approve you and disburse the funds within one or two business days, sometimes even on the same day.
Home Equity Loans: The process is far more involved and can take anywhere from two to six weeks or even longer. It functions like a second mortgage application and requires a home appraisal, a title search, and extensive underwriting.
The Bottom Line: If time is a major concern, an unsecured personal loan is the clear winner for its speed and convenience.
Fact #4: You Can Only Get a Home Equity Loan if You've Built Up... Well, Equity
This may seem obvious, but it's a common stumbling block for new homeowners. You cannot borrow against your home's equity if you don't have any. Lenders typically require you to have at least 15-20% equity in your home to even qualify for a home equity loan. The amount you can borrow is usually capped at around 80% to 85% of your home's value, minus the outstanding mortgage balance.
Personal loans, on the other hand, have no such requirement. They are available to both homeowners and renters alike, as long as you meet the lender's credit, income, and debt-to-income ratio requirements.
The Bottom Line: If you're a recent homeowner, a personal loan is likely your only option among the two.
Fact #5: One May Offer a Tax Benefit, But Only for a Specific Purpose
This is a crucial point that can significantly impact the long-term cost of your loan. Interest paid on a home equity loan may be tax-deductible, but only under a very specific condition set by the IRS. The funds from the home equity loan must be used to "buy, build, or substantially improve" the home that secures the loan. This is a major advantage for those using the loan for home renovations.
Interest on a personal loan is almost never tax-deductible, regardless of how you use the funds.
The Bottom Line: If your primary reason for borrowing is a major home renovation, the potential for a tax deduction on the interest makes a home equity loan an even more compelling financial choice. Always consult a tax professional to be sure.
Fact #6: One is Better for Smaller, Quick Costs; The Other for Large, Long-Term Projects
The sweet spot for each loan type often comes down to the amount of money you need.
Personal Loans: These are ideal for smaller to mid-sized expenses, typically ranging from a few thousand dollars up to $50,000 or $100,000 for well-qualified borrowers. They are perfect for things like emergency car repairs, a wedding, debt consolidation of a manageable amount, or a small home improvement project.
Home Equity Loans: Since they are secured, lenders are often willing to lend much larger sums, sometimes up to hundreds of thousands of dollars. This makes them more suitable for substantial projects like a major home addition, a complete kitchen or bathroom remodel, or consolidating a significant amount of high-interest debt.
The Bottom Line: For a smaller or immediate need, a personal loan is more practical. For a large-scale project that requires a substantial amount of capital, a home equity loan is often a better fit.
Fact #7: Their Application Fees and Closing Costs Are Very Different
The true cost of a loan isn't just the interest rate; it's also the fees.
Personal Loans: Many personal loans have no fees at all. Some, however, may charge an origination fee, which is a percentage of the loan amount deducted from the total before you receive it. This fee is typically a few percent, for example, 1-6%.
Home Equity Loans: Because they are treated like a second mortgage, they come with substantial closing costs, which can range from 2% to 5% of the loan amount. These costs cover things like a home appraisal, title search, attorney fees, and loan origination fees.
The Bottom Line: Even if a home equity loan has a lower interest rate, you must factor in the closing costs. On a smaller loan, these costs can easily wipe out any interest savings. This makes a personal loan particularly attractive for smaller borrowing needs.
Fact #8: Their Impact on Your Credit Score Is Not Equal
Both loans affect your credit, but in different ways.
Personal Loans: Applying for a personal loan results in a hard inquiry, which can temporarily drop your score by a few points. Once approved, the loan adds to your credit mix (adding installment debt to revolving debt), which can be a positive. It will be reported to the credit bureaus, and on-time payments will build your credit history.
Home Equity Loans: The application process also results in a hard inquiry. However, because it's a second mortgage, it increases your total debt and can potentially impact your debt-to-income ratio, which lenders consider. The key difference is that by taking out a home equity loan, you are reducing your home equity, which is an asset. While this may not directly impact your credit score, it can affect your ability to get future loans and signals to other lenders that you have less ownership in your home.
The Bottom Line: While both affect your credit, a home equity loan ties your financial health directly to your home's value, which can be volatile. A personal loan's impact is more isolated to your credit report.
Making the Right Choice: A Quick Decision-Making Guide
Now that you know the 8 surprising facts, here’s a simple checklist to help you decide.
Choose a Personal Loan if:
- You are a new homeowner with little to no equity.
- You need funds quickly for an emergency.
- The borrowing amount is relatively small ($5,000 - $30,000).
- You do not want to risk your home as collateral.
- You don't want to deal with a lengthy application process and closing costs.
Choose a Home Equity Loan if:
- You have significant equity built up in your home.
- You need a large sum of money for a substantial project.
- You are comfortable with using your home as collateral.
- Your project is a major home renovation, and you can potentially deduct the interest.
- You can wait several weeks for the funds to be disbursed.
Understanding the fundamental differences between a personal loan and a home equity loan is the first step toward making a smart financial move. Both are valuable tools, but they are designed for different purposes and come with unique risks and benefits. By considering these 8 facts, you can confidently choose the loan that aligns with your financial goals, risk tolerance, and timeline.
Ready to find the right loan for you?
Whether it’s a personal loan or a home equity loan, our platform can help. Compare personalized offers from our network of trusted lenders and get the right financing for your needs.
